I think we need ANOTHER explanation of how 'constructive critisizim' works. Okay so here is how it works
The beautiful world of constructive critisim:
Step 1: Write a story on forums. By doing that you are offering up your work to be judged by others so don't bother if you are not thick-skinned.
Step 2: I read your story. I think in some way it can be improved. I tell you how it can be done. BECAUSE YOU OFFERED UP YOUR STORY FOR CRITISIZM AND THAT IS WHAT I WILL GIVE.
Step 3: Use said critisizm to IMPROVE said story, thank the giver (BECAUSE IT WAS YOUR CHOICE TO PUT THE STORY UP) and then publish your book and sell it for £££ or $$$ or some other symbol.
BUT, I have to say I don't like this attitude:
You do this to an editor and your NEVER gonna get published. THEY aren't there to reassure you that your story is good and I sure as hell am not either. THEY are there to make sure that England's books are READABLE. So, all you aspiring writers, I want you to learn something from this post today, and that is:
STOP. THE. ATTITUDE.
I'm only here to HELP you. This will only make you STRONGER. or has that weird radio song from Kelly Clarkson taught you NOTHING?
And stop with the exaggeration. I never say like 'oh your story was rubbish i hated it'. I put stuff like 'it's too fast paced' or mostly 'you need to improve grammar/spelling'. Completely valid arguments. I think MORE of us should use constructive critsim rather than shielding our friends feelings, if they REALLY want to be an author. Don't even shield MINE.
Also peepz, take a warning from this. I rarely offer praise as i'm more conditioned to telling you how you can improve, so PLEASE don't ask me to comment on your stories unless you can take it. >_<
Well i hope we all LEARNED something today. :)
Apart from the fact I am mean when it comes to story commenting.
This isn't right. You are completely correct. If you were to offer up your story people (like you) will post their thoughts to help you improve your work!
ReplyDeleteO: How can she call yuh mean?! Yuhr the most kind person on moviestarplanet even though I'm not friends with you and I barley know yuh. just from other people!!
ReplyDeleteMuch Love
~Megsie-rules1
You were mean?! What?? I make some stories on forums and I like being critisized because then I know that my story can be better next time :L
ReplyDelete